In the fast-paced world of crypto, Digital Asset Treasury companies—or DATs for short—are gaining attention. These are essentially firms that hold significant amounts of digital assets like Bitcoin in their treasuries, and investors are buzzing about how to value them properly. Recently, Matt Hougan, the Chief Investment Officer at Bitwise Investments, shared a detailed thread on X breaking down the common misconceptions around DAT valuations. His insights are particularly relevant for anyone in the meme token space, where community-driven projects often involve holding or managing digital assets in innovative ways.
Hougan starts by challenging the "bad analysis" he sees floating around. He introduces the concept of mNAV, which stands for modified Net Asset Value—basically, the value of the assets a DAT holds, adjusted for various factors. The big question: Should these companies trade at, above, or below their mNAV? To unpack this, Hougan suggests imagining the DAT has a fixed lifespan, like it's shutting down and distributing assets soon. This thought experiment helps strip away the noise.
For a super short-term scenario, say the company is liquidating today, it would trade exactly at its asset value—no discounts or premiums. But stretch that to a year, and things get interesting. Discounts come into play due to illiquidity (you can't access the assets right away), expenses (like executive pay eating into holdings), and risks (what if something goes wrong?). On the flip side, premiums might arise if the DAT can grow its crypto holdings per share over time.
Hougan outlines four main strategies DATs use to boost their crypto-per-share:
Issuing debt: Borrow in USD, buy crypto, and hope it appreciates to pay off the debt and pocket the extra. This is how companies like MicroStrategy have ramped up their Bitcoin stacks.
Lending crypto: Earn interest by lending out holdings, increasing overall assets.
Using derivatives: Things like writing call options to generate income, though this caps upside potential.
Acquiring at a discount: Snap up locked assets cheaply, buy other DATs on sale, repurchase shares, or even acquire cash-flow businesses to funnel profits into more crypto.
What stands out is the asymmetry: Discounts from expenses and risks are pretty certain, while premium drivers are more speculative. That's why most DATs might trade at a discount, with only top performers earning a premium. And size matters—bigger DATs have advantages in debt issuance, lending, and deals.
Extending this to indefinite lifespans amplifies everything. Ongoing expenses compound, but so does the value from consistent growth in holdings. For meme token enthusiasts, this framework could apply to projects with treasuries or DAOs managing community funds. Think about how a meme coin's treasury might use similar tactics to increase token value per holder, minus the corporate structure.
Hougan's thread is a must-read for anyone eyeing crypto investments beyond spot trading. Check out the original thread on X for the full breakdown. As the crypto landscape evolves, understanding these valuation nuances can give you an edge, whether you're building a meme empire or just hodling through the volatility.